Week 2: Sgraffitto
Restoration Ethics
Second week Restoration Theory lectures started out with the actual ethics of conservation/restoration: what is ethical to do or not do, and how. There's a general trend between American/English attitudes and then Italian attitudes around how to restore things. A/E attitude is more market-responsive and therefore more mimetic - it tries to hide damage in a seamless way; whereas Italian strategies are more transparent in what's original versus restored and are more responsive to historical inquiry than the market. My general view is that every artwork should be considered on a case by case basis, balancing factors such as patron/client, audience, expense of restorative action, historical value, etc. The topic of repatriation was raised by a fellow classmate, but we didn't get too into it because a future lecture addresses the concept of "cultural property" and we'll dive into it more then. One of my firm opinions there is that when it comes to cultural objects, to the best of our knowledge and ability, representatives of the origin culture should be directly involved in the discussion. The consideration of "do they have the means to properly steward this object" comes up and in my opinion, it isn't right for the institution of a museum, for example, to assert that "we know best, we know better than you, and we'll make this decision for you." We can't infantilize other people and control their decisions on what came from their people. There are gray areas regarding what constitutes the “origin culture” as well, and I love the gray area of this field, but for the sake of time and relevancy I won’t get into it further for now.
Our next lecture with Max had to do with wholeness/deterioration and "potential unity" with ideas about how a cultural object is considered in states of wholeness/potential unity, fragmentation where we can infer about the subject or context, ruin where we have no discernible subject or context, memory where we don't have the object itself anymore, and disturbance where we only see evidence that an object was there but lack memory/subject/context. Potential unity refers to when deterioration occurs, where is the line where we lose the ability to understand the "gist" of it? For example, think of a painting of people conversing with a building in the background. If we lose small pieces here and there, no problem understanding. If we lose a large chunk that still retains meaningful portions of the people and building, we can infer an understanding that is reasonable, but if we lose large chunks that obfuscate "connective tissue" in the image or elements entirely, then we cannot fully understand what we look at and the unity is entirely gone (generally). Discussion also touched on what to do - reconstruction of a total loss, make a copy of something, etc. - given the resources that you have access to. Many moving parts go into the ultimate decisions on how to act on an artwork.
Next, Max focused on restoration methods, elaborating on the differences of certain applications such as tonal modulation (where the lacunae or gap/loss is filled in with a variety of tonal applications from lighter versions of the appropriate color of the original to chromatic abstraction which is kind of hmm, visually fuzzy? but draws less attention to the lacunae) as well as integration methods such as artistic restoration (making up what's lost, typically considered unethical) or mimetic/semi-mimetic methods which are more common in the US. Regardless of philosophies (mimetic/trattegio/etc.) the general the goal is always a harmonious integration.
Our last lecture of the week had to do with the issue of completion: when we choose to finish an incomplete work or not depending on concerns such as whether an individual made it (usually for paintings) or a group (usually buildings), does it have greater significance/value in its unfinished state (like a famous portrait of George Washington) or to be finished (a building), that kind of thing. We looked at some examples of churches in Florence and how they were addressed or not in terms of finish; if so, how successful is it; if not, why.
Painting Theory
Painting theory lectures began with aggregates of binders - substances like rock, sand, lime, etc. that provide structure to binders; and how they interact and what properties they have. For our final, we were expected to have a solid conceptual understanding of what's happening and why - what sets in water and what sets in air, why, etc. Then we went over mural techniques; reviewing lime-based techniques of fresco (+half fresco and polishing fresco) and sgraffito, then the dry techniques of oil, tempera on wall and painting with liquid silicates. In our last lecture guided by Sofia, she reviewed what it takes to make a wall painting and the preparatory elements/practices. We touched on gilding techniques for wall and panel/canvas.
Workshop
In the workshop, we sieved the coarse sand to get the fine sand for the plaster, then mixed that with marble dust and powdered pigment to make the plaster ground for our sgraffito.
Mixing the colored plaster for the sgraffito. Photo taken by my professor, Fabiola Vitali.
After spreading that on our mortar and leaving it to set, we went to scale-up our drawings with the squaring method again for the transfer onto the sgraffito block. Our next step was to mix the top layer of plaster, a 1:1 mix of water and gypsum powder and brushed it on in alternating horizontal and vertical layers until it had built up 6-7mm thick.
Applying the final layer of plaster, portions of which will be removed to create the sgraffito designs. Photo taken by Fabiola.
Then we transferred our drawings onto the plaster with indirect engraving (laying the drawing over and using a stick to impress it into the damp plaster) before starting to outline the drawing directly with a sculpting tool. We progressively remove plaster until the image is clear.
The engraved design. Photo taken by Fabiola.Although tracing the information was challenging, I think my chosen design is from the facade of the Piazza dei Cavalieri in Pisa and I believe it's designed by Vasari but executed by Alessandro Forzori and Tomasso Battista del Verocchio. I liked the fish and it was visually pleasing but reasonably challenging to execute for the time given, so I was satisfied by my effort in the end.
Initially we begin to outline the design before removing the major negative space areas. Photo by Mark.Working through the sgraffito. Photo by Mark.
Midway progress.To prepare for gilding with Fabiola on wooden panel in the second half of the program, those of us who had completed our sgraffito practiced gilding on our frescoes. The panels will be harder to gild because they’re smooth as compared to the textured plaster. Ordinarily, I wouldn't have added gilding to this as it wasn't part of the original fresco and I do think the results are a bit gaudy, but it was really cool to get a feel for the process and handling the sheets of gold leaf (which is not real gold, although Fabiola said that's what she learned on at Tuscia!). At the end of the week, we cleaned up our sgraffitos. For me this mostly meant increasing the contrast as I luckily didn't have major damage or loss of the original design.
My completed sgraffito after cleaning up the errors. Quite pleased overall with the result!
Fabiola guiding me through the gilding. Here she's applying the mission which will dry part way and become tacky, then we carefully add the gold leaf. Photo taken by Sofia.
Applying the mission, myself, for the gilding. Photo by Sofia.
Fabiola showing how to handle the sheets of gold leaf. Photo by Sofia.Mine and my classmates' work.
Viterbo
Fabiola and a guide named Michele took us to Viterbo this week, starting at Tuschia University where Fabiola got her degree in conservation and where Michele teaches museum studies and art history. In Italy, for reasonable tuition, you can go to college, and at this university, you can specifically study in conservation- you could likely live here and get a degree for like half of what we pay just to attend at all in the states. Furthermore, this is an undergrad university. The requirements to reach a career in art restoration in Italy vs. the States are radically different and I can’t help feeling envious of the young people we talked to! We toured the laboratories where the students get hands-on experience because the college partners with museums and private clients to restore artworks. It was very cool to see what they have access to and to get a feel for what it's like to actually gain practical experience at an undergrad level.
Talking with one of Fabiola's former professors in the laboratories. Photo by Fabiola.After the university we went to the
Church of Santa Maria della Verita where we looked at murals restored after bombings during WWII. It was not only extremely beautiful, but a wonderful example of the practices we're learning about in class, such as trattegio, a method of restoration where from far away you can't tell but up close you can because the painting restoration is done with small linear marks that make it clear enough what's original or not.
From there we drove a little further out to the highest area of Viterbo, arriving at the Duomo's Hill Monumental Complex and then navigating around that area, starting with Saint Lawrence Cathedral. The area itself around the Duomo is beautiful, lots of stunning architecture and views.
Architecture around the Monumental Complex.
Inside the Saint Lawrence Cathedral.
In the afternoon, we went to the city center - it was incredible to see these murals still intact the way they are - this is how a lot of medieval and Renaissance churches actually looked, with full coverage of artworks. The religious content doesn't move me personally through iconography, but the artwork itself is breathtaking. I can't believe I didn't take any photos here, I was just so impressed by them and we kept getting caught up discussing the methodology and class concepts.
One of our final stops was the Civic Museum's smaller location - it's actually attached to the Church of Santa Maria della Verita but undergoing renovations. This second location is accessible and houses only two artworks, both by Sebastiano del Piombo, one of the most important Italian Renaissance artists for his moment of history. The two works housed there are panel paintings on wood and correspond to the time right before the transition from panel to canvas being most common as a structure. Canvas is more portable and more economic. This is also around the time that oil went from being an additive to binders to being the sole binder with pigments (and we get the oil paint that we're familiar with today), so there's a remarkable depth to his paintings. We were also able to see the back, because of how they're displayed, which is rare, and allowed us to better consider the structure of panel paintings and the thoughtfulness that went into them. The last place we stopped in is, tragically, a church whose name I completely forget. But it's ceiling murals were also incredible.
Pieta, Sebastiano del Piombo, c. 1517, image from Jstor.
Michele telling us about the Pieta. Photo by Fabiola.I was so impressed with how this artwork is shown in the gallery and how they've accommodated viewing of the back of the panel. It was a treat to get to see the drawings made there!
Michele was so knowledgeable about everything. I sincerely appreciate how much he shared with us as well as the discussions with Fabiola about the process and structure of things, it was really cool to witness real-world examples of what we've been talking about.
Rome
We also went to Rome this week with Sofia. We started at the Barberini Palace, now a museum, where we learned about the history of the building, how it was sort of a palace and about the conjunction of religious and political power that was housed there. I generally struggle to retain the historical knowledge in semi-lecture form without being able to take notes as points of reference, but it was rewarding listening to the guide’s expertise and the artwork was extremely stimulating to look at. Lots of exquisite architectural decoration and murals, as well as paintings on the walls of course. We spent time in the Caravaggio room specifically, looking at work by him and his students. After the guide left us, Sofia had us look further at the concepts relevant to our class- where wooden panels create seams, areas of visible retouching, and so on.
We walked around the area to have lunch, passing by the Trevi Fountain.
Beautiful, but quite the tourist trap!Then we passed the Pantheon, which is pretty incredible, but since 2020 they've made it paid admission and we didn’t have the time that day to wait in the remarkable line through the plaza. I appreciated that we took some time to talk about the exterior of the building and the restoration work done there, however. Our last major stop was the Basilica di Saint Maria Sopra Minerva, a gothic church with an austere exterior. I was most taken by the rose windows, but there were also accessibly visible areas of restoration in the columns and ceiling we studied.
Unfortunately, I didn’t get the chance to experience the romance I associate with Rome’s reputation and we were on a whirlwind itinerary through the day, but what a beautiful city! I understand the draw and how one could spend their entire, long vacation just exploring this area.
Guest Lecture: Simona Salvo
Our guest lecture during the second week was hosted by Simona Salvo. She talked about Italian history, initially from the context of the area being highly seismic with the volcanoes, and the idea of continuity of material usage out of necessity (prior to industrialization). Rome didn't “fall” the way we imagine- the emperor-center moves to Constantinople in the 5th century and it's not until the 10th century that the city faces physical destruction. This destruction leads to spolia - the "looting" of materials to relocate to other areas of the region. Because quarries were not available at this point (I believe due to man power lost from city destruction but I don’t recall her explanation exactly) and couldn't be created, they took marble (and more) from Rome in large pieces - for example you have full columns removed and used in Vatican City - and then in progressively smaller pieces. Decorative elements were shown off proudly as a part of heritage. Approximately 1/3 of spolia was broken down and baked for limestone mortar, Salvo emphasized the practice of reuse as well as the idea of rubble as heritage. She actually opened with this, the 2016 earthquake of Amatrice and how about half the people wanted to come back and found so much value in the rubble that was left. Salvo mentioned the current state of Gaza as well (I was grateful to see strong evidence in general in San Gemini of support of Palestine). Through rebuilding and reuse, there's a symbolic value, and in Italy, a connection to Classical times which are here considered the height of civilization. I found this idea of “rubble as heritage” the most interesting part of her talk.
Salvo went on- Raffaele Stem "froze" the colosseum arch in its moment of deterioration in 1807, preserving it - keeping it from further deterioration while also not restoring it. This is, she said, a Romantic ideology. Industrialization causes a gap in this general behavior of reuse and changes everything. The San Marco bell tower collapses, and rather than rebuilding it with the existing material, instead it's rebuilt with reinforced concrete and the rubble wasn't reused. Mussolini levels a hill and buildings and there's no documentation as to where that physical content went. Rubble from various Ally bombs in Germany and Italy were made into hills, such as in Teufelsberg and Monte Stella. The modern idea that everything should be made anew and not reuse old materials causes this conundrum of what to do with the material, and these hills were one answer. In the 20th century, Cesare Brandi (loosely the father of modern Italian restoration) develops the idea of a relationship between the viewer and the art, the idea that fragments have significance, they hold the potential of artwork they originate from.
The Basilica of Saint Francis in Assisi suffered an earthquake in 1997. Two of the vaults came down and three men died. By chance, the day before, a full photographic survey had been completed, so they had evidence of everything as it had been. This began what Salvo called the "Utopia Project," where the intent was to put every piece back, just as it had been, and she worked on the project. This was loosely her throughline across the discussion to connect her various points. After she finished, Max engaged Salvo in a discussion about the practicality of the Utopia Project and they lightly debated the value of attempting to put every single recovered piece back in its original position and how that effort sits in relationship to Italian restoration attitudes as well as practical use of a space for its intended purpose.
The Weekend:
During the middle weekend, I took time from studying to get a souvenir tattoo in Terni- I met with a lovely Italian artist who brought her son to translate, and the experience was short but sweet. Thanks to her willingness to work out communications with me, I’ve now been tattooed on three continents!






































Comments
Post a Comment